There have been two books published this year by lawyers which I have read and highly commend. The first is “The Valley – Crime and Punishment in a New Zealand City”, written by Asher Emanuel and published by Bridget Williams Books. The second is “Nothing But the Truth”, written by Stuart Grieve KC and published by Allen & Unwin. Both are concerned with criminal cases.
Asher Emanuel is a Wellington lawyer. The book is an account of a lawyer practising in the Public Defence Service and representing a number of clients (two in particular) who appear frequently in the criminal courts on relatively minor charges but leading to periods of imprisonment. The names of the lawyer and the clients are fictional but fhe events are factual and, one suspects, are an account of cases and clients for whom Emanuel has acted.
The picture that emerges is of young men who are constantly in trouble with the law. The lawyer’s task is one of achieving a satisfactory outcome – conviction without imprisonment – by persuading the client to face reality and then to negotiate a deal with the police and then a non- custodial sentence from the Judge. A prominent feature was the existence of the SCC – the Special Circumstances Court – in which a Duty Solicitor assisted in obtaining the Court to defer prosecutions while rehabilitative steps were taken. This included finding accommodation for the client and referring him to mental health services. The efficacy of these measures was often sub-optimal because of the client not being sufficiently co-operative but also because of inadequacies in the resources being applied. This had led the Duty Solicitor in the book, “in a lifetime around the criminal justice system” becoming “deeply frustrated by what wasn’t being done”.
The problems that faced District Court Judges in securing housing for defendants whose situation was caused by a lack of accommodation. As the book recounts, just about everyone who came before the courts was disadvantaged in every way, needing health care, education and housing, which the courts could not provide. This leads the author, in the concluding chapter of the book, to comment on the political changes that have been made in recent years to the criminal justice system and to effects that they have had on the numbers in prisons. He points to the innovation, initiated by Judges and lawyers, of special needs courts but refers to the limits of these measures occasioned by the “absence of any special resourcing for the solutions which are required - housing, drug and alcohol treatment, mental health care, education and training – [which] means that, at best, therapeutic courts are attempting to connect people with existing services8 which are facing their own resource strains”. Judges and lawyers, he says, have no power over taxation or appropriations which are the domain of Parliament or over the delivery of social programmes which are the domain of the executive. “There is nothing the judges or the lawyers can do about the unavailability of public housing, the waitlists for rehab, and the fraying patchwork of care services which are supposed to provide medical, psychiatric and social support”, he rightly says.
Emanuel acknowledges the place for reform of the criminal law and procedure and “the worsening resource pressures on the court processes and the various parties involved – defence counsel, police, probation and the prison service”. But, more significant than that, he says, is what has happened before someone ever comes to court, which “have more to do with the health, education and housing systems than they do with criminal justice policy.” Much incarceration, for relatively minor offending, masks the lack of better alternatives to deal with acute mental health disorders. This, he says, is a political problem that requires a political solution.
This book and the messages that it gives, is highly recommended reading not only for lawyers but for politicians, particularly those who parade under the law and order banner.
Stuart Grieve’s “Nothing But the Truth” addresses more serious crime and focuses on famous cases in which he has played a part as counsel. The most spectacular of these was the Plumley Walker case in which a cricket umpire died while under the custody of Renee Chignall who worked as a dominatrix. While it was not suggested that she killed him while administering to his desires, she and her boyfriend were charged with murder when they threw his body over the Huka Falls, the issue being whether he was alive when he thrown. It took a third trial before the pair were finally acquitted. At the heart of the case was expert evidence from pathologists as to whether the cause of death was drowning or asphyxia caused by being voluntarily hung on a hook. Another feature of the case was evidence given by prisoners who had shared cells with the defendants when on remand and who testified that the defendants had told them that Plumley Walker was alive when he was thrown into the river. Ultimately, the evidence of the prisoner who claimed that Chignall had confessed to her was discredited by cross-examination at trial. A further issue concerned the claim by a police officer who interviewed Chignell that she had confessed “murder” to him. The manner in which the interview was conducted was explored in cross examination and the jury’s acquittal demonstrated its unfairness and unreliability.
Other major cases discussed by Grieve include the Crewe murders and the trials of Arthur Allan Thomas who was ultimately pardoned and paid compensation for the time he spent in jail after being convicted. He also describes in detail his cross examination of a doctor who had been sued by his wife for exemplary damages for continuing violence and rape. A further exemplary damages case in which he was involved, together with his barrister wife, Antonia Fisher, was a claim against Dr Bottrill who had been found guilty in a medical disciplinary hearing of negligently misreading cervical smear tests. The claim failed in the first instance by virtue of the Judge applying a restrictive test to the degree of negligence required to be established to found an exemplary damages verdict but the Judge later ordered a retrial. That order was reversed on appeal but reinstated by the Privy Council on further appeal.
Of considerable interest is Grieve’s account of the Royal Commission of Inquiry that was established to investigate the crash of an Air New Zealand plane that crashed into Mt Erebus in the Antarctic while on a sight-seeing flight. He represented the Civil Aviation Division of the Ministry of Transport. The Royal Commissioner, Justice Peter Mahon, gave a report that exonerated the pilot and found Air New Zealand blameworthy changing the co-ordinates of the flight plan without alerting the flight crew. That report was highly controversial and a criticism of Air New Zealand was reviewed in part by an appeal by Air New Zealand to the Privy Council. Stuart Grieve, who had a pilot’s licence himself, concludes that the cause of the crash was the result of multiple failure both of Air New Zealand and of the pilots descending to an unsafe height.
Another chapter of considerable interest is the part that Grieve played in being appointed as special counsel in two high profile matters – the refugee claim by Ahmed Zaoui and the extradition proceedings involving Kim Dotcom whose extradition was sought by the United States of America. In the first case, his task was to review as counsel appointed to represent Zaoui for the purpose (but without disclosure to his normal lawyers) confidential evidence held by the Government Communications Security Bureau to determine whether it justified his detention by the Security Intelligence Service. He ultimately thought that it did not and Zaoui was later cleared by the SIS.
Grieve’s role in the Dotcom case was similar. He was appointed by the Court to examine material held by the Government Communications Security Bureau that was claimed to be classified and that, if disclosed, would prejudice New Zealand’s national security by revealing intelligence gathering and sharing methods. His task was to review the classified information and to appear for Dotcom in a closed court hearing where neither he nor his lawyers would be present. The material was, at his request, taken to and kept in his Chambers but in a large safe. His staff were forbidden from entering his office while he was examining documents. An application was eventually made by Dotcom’s normal lawyers that Grieve’s appointment should be rescinded and to view the documents themselves but both applications were declined.
Stuart Grieve has been one of the pre-eminent barristers practising in the area of criminal law, initially as a prosecutor but later as defence counsel. His book is welcome as providing many insights into the conduct of criminal cases.
13 November 2026
James Farmer KC